Awesomeness in a jar.

“Awesome Nut Butters” is Nutty Novelties’ tagline, and boy, they sure are. They make eighteen different flavors of nut butters that are high in protein, low in sugar, all natural, and made in Telford, PA.

Nutty Novelties began in 2012 by Caleb Mangum making build-your-own trail mix bars, but quickly pivoted to exclusively making nut butters by 2014. By this time, Caleb’s brother, Jesse, joined the team and they haven’t looked back since.

They offer classic peanut, almond and cashew butters (plain and flavored), but their real awesomeness is their unique combinations and use of different nuts. Habanero Honey Peanut Butter, Butterscotch Peanut Butter, Pistachio Butter, White Chocolate Walnut Butter are a few examples of their fun varieties.

We caught up with Jesse recently and asked him a few questions:

What is a positive or negative things that came out of the pandemic for your business? The pandemic presented many challenges for our business, but none more than the canceling of craft shows and events which are a big part of our business. However, may of the grocery stores that we wholesale to were busier.

Favorite part of your job? Interacting with happy customers – both other businesses and consumers. 

What would you like new customers to know about you that they may not find on your website? Hablo Española

Favorite product? Cappuccino Peanut Butter of course!

One word to describe you? Trustworthy  

We currently have their Butterscotch Peanut Butter in stock if you'd like to try some awesomeness. It’s perfect for adding to any gift box or to try out on your next piece of toast.